Lifting the lid on the world of football

The Secret Footballer
13 Oct, 2012

This position I’ve held, it pays my way

The following column is an open letter to a previous manager:

There’s a club if you’d like to go, you could meet somebody who really loves you, so you go and you stand on your own, and you leave on your own, and you go home and you cry and you want to die.

Perhaps I was played out of position or perhaps football had simply moved on and I had failed to adapt. Whatever the truth (and a huge amount has been written on it) I will always maintain that I was played out of position.

Signing for a new club is a nerve-racking experience, especially if you happen to be a big money signing. I knew I was a good player but the change was simply too much to take all in one go, not least for my wife and, perhaps inevitably, I ended up parting ways with the club on less than amicable terms while my wife and I attempted to make sense of the wreckage that we had once called our marriage.

Notwithstanding one or two individuals (that shall remain nameless) holding a metaphorical gun to my head, the move was my fault. I gambled the happiness and the wellbeing of the people I love the most for the possibility of a few more people singing my name for a few more years and for a few more quid.

You live and learn.

Aside from all the things that I could have done to prevent the move, I do wish that I’d been more vocal as to why things were not going to plan. But when you are at a new club and you don’t really know the motives of the people around you, the whole thing can become a lonely and depressing saga.

It wouldn’t have taken a lot, a carefully worded sentence to the right journalist would at least have provided a footballing reason for my slow start. Something like; ‘I am very committed to the club and although I’m happy to be part of the team, I look forward to playing in the position that I’m used to.’

You shut your mouth, how can you say I go about things the wrong way?

I have said more often than I care to remember that football at the top level, that is to say the Champions League and International competition, will only be won for the foreseeable future by teams that are prepared to abandon conventional formations (442, 433 etc.). Instead there is a crucial need to adopt a more fluid brand of football where attacking the opponent is concerned.

Typing that again now feels almost like a waste of time, so obvious is movement and ball retention to the fortunes of many teams. But when I proposed that very idea no more than 6 or 7 years ago, I was laughed out of the coach’s office. In fact I can remember the first team coach saying to me; ‘you really don’t know a lot about football do you?’ This was a man that failed dismally as a manager in his own right in a previous life.

Perhaps his reaction was less to do with what I know about football and more to do with the fact that at the time only Barcelona could claim to employ anything near the concept of six inter changeable attacking players. They fielded a combination of Edmilson, Ronaldinho, Deco, Xavi, Iniesta, Guily, Larsson and, at times, a very young Lionel Messi. But at that time even Barcelona were starting most matches with a recognized centre forward in Samuel Eto’o.

The latest ‘word’ to come out of Barcelona is that the conventional centre half will follow the conventional forward in being will be the next major change in top-level football. Javier Mascherano has already proved that a midfield player that is comfortable on the ball can play at centre half, and if you think about it, a centre back is very often the starting point of a team’s attack. Now that Alex Song has signed from Arsenal, don’t be surprised to see the Barcelona team of the future line up with two former centre midfielders as their recognized centre back pairing.

I am human and I need to be loved, just like everybody else does.

Watching the game at Wembley last night, I felt that England actually had a great opportunity to break the mould for a change, rather than follow the herd. How refreshing it would have been to see two ball playing centre midfielders playing at centre half, players that could have brought the ball out of defence with a purpose and genuinely contribute to the attacks, upping the tempo when required.

Where was the real need to play Cahill and Jagielka? The media were dreaming if they thought that by listing England’s previous highest scoring games, they were going to get anything other than the thoroughly predictable. It was an opportunity missed and, perhaps sadder still, one that probably never even found its way in to Roy Hodgson’s thoughts.

I was struck at how little in the way of football intelligence was on show during the game, despite playing the worst team in the world. If a team are setting themselves up not to get beat, then why try to play straight through the middle of them by way of stupid little flicks and blind ‘round the corner’ passes? England did this for the entire first 25 minutes.

The ball should be moved high up the pitch as quickly as possible, from side to side and inside full backs until an opposition player can’t recover his position. Then, generally, a winger gets in behind to cut the ball back.

In five or six years time when Tom Cleverly and Jack Wilshere (ed: corrected) are hopefully able to step in to England’s midfield on a regular basis, we will perhaps begin to see the fruits of what we have learnt from the very best teams. But by that point, who knows what Barcelona and Spain will be doing.

When you say it’s gonna happen “now”, well when exactly do you mean?
See I’ve already waited too long, and all my hope is gone.

With special thanks to The Smiths.

About the author: The Secret Footballer

 

I’ve seen everything there is to see in football, and a lot more outside of it. My anonymity let’s me tell you how it is, from inside the game without the shackles of pre-conception or fan bias.

Related articles

Have your say

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <b> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike>

Other comments

  1. spilchard

    “I’d been bought for a lot of money but wasn’t used the way I thought I was going to be. I was given 10 games. One I was played left midfield and the majority of the others centre midfield and you’d have to ask Tony Pulis why that was.”

    Stop Me If You’ve Heard This One Before

  2. Morrissey

    Best piece in ages!

  3. spilchard

    The second half of the story is that TSK was played as an understudy target man rather than in a creative role, and his game fell apart as a result. Plus moving clubs wrecked his marriage temporarily. He went back to his old club on loan after 18 matches. I’m not sure whether all of this is in previous TSK articles but I’m pretty surethat’s what happened. Under those circumstances the sentiments of “How Soon is Now?” are spot on. But TSK thrives on spontaneity, and England last night in the context of his creative thinking at Stoke fit the song too, especially the title.

  4. Neil

    Normally love TSF but this post is a bit of a game of two halves. I was waiting to hear about what happened at the club but somehow it segued into a discussion of last night’s match.

  5. spilchard

    Ah yes, poor old Dave Kemp again. First team coach at Stoke under Tony Pulis, after dreadfull spell as manager of Oxford United after Joe Kinnear left. I remember him at Argyle. TSK compared him to Phil Neale under Graham Taylor in previous article.

  6. Birdy

    Who is Luke Wilshire? Completely agree with you however. It’s taken Fergie 5 years to realise Rooney can be a perfect Scholes and he’s the greatest manager in England. You should always strive for the best and learn from the best… Surely other people will notice that every player must be a total footballer soon.

  7. David

    Typo – Jack, not Luke Wilshere…

  8. Behemoth

    Luke Wilshire or Jack Wilshere?

  9. Paul Groves

    Much as I love reading your comments I do hope you realise that without knowing what club tou play for, who you are and what the “story” is it could all be made up…..perhaps we wouldn’t care. I suspect when you are writing there must be the thought that no-one really gives a shit about a bleating rich footballer. But then I suppose to expose yourself would mean…what do I do now?

  10. Rhys Sprules

    Very interesting to see a footballers view on the future of tactics! I wonder if you have read ‘soccernomics’ the football book confronting footballing cliches and norms. It describes how the Central European countries will always be ahead of England as we are far from the core of footballing knowledge, this is a perfect example of the arrogance shown by managers which is also presented in the book, that is that the English game is full of head figures who are very adverse to new thinking and ways of playing!
    I can imagine that being played out of position for a pro footballer is extremely frustrating, as in ‘their’ position is where they have been successful and made a name for themselves. A column on reactions of previous players you’ve played with when they have been forced to play in a different position would be interesting and how managers deal with it would be great.

  11. Sam

    Luke Wilshire?

  12. Jack

    Luke Wilshire???
    Accidental hint that TSF is Australian I reckon haha

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <b> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike>

Latest articles